USANYGarden City12 5Th Pl
View of front facade featuring stucco siding and a front lawn | Image 1
Link Copied

12 5th Pl, Garden City, NY

House

Sold

Listed price in listed location currency (USD).
$1,300,000
$1,299,000

430

MLS® 867709

  • Key Facts
  • Description
  • Rooms
  • Map

Key Facts

Type Single Family Residence
Levels Residential
Size 1959 sqft
Garage Yes
Taxes $16,776
Lot Size 
Approx. Age 1898
Avg. Price Per Sqft $663
MLS® Number 867709

Property Address: 12 5th Pl, Garden City, NY, 11530-6105

Average square foot calculated using Size range provided by listing agent.

Description

Step into a piece of Garden City history with this beautifully restored Colonial, one of only 18 original "Workman's Cottage" built during the lifetime of founder Alexander Stewart in the late 1890s. Thoughtfully renovated and expanded for modern living, this home seamlessly blends timeless charm with contemporary comfort. A two-story addition that included excavation of basement enhances the space with a stunning kitchen great room, a luxurious primary suite with walk-in closets and ensuite bath, and a fully excavated basement designed for family fun and entertainment. Inside, you'll find a sun-filled formal living room with gas fireplace, an inviting eat-in kitchen featuring white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a large peninsula for casual dining. The kitchen flows effortlessly into a bright eating area and the open-concept family room, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Sliding glass doors lead to a serene backyard with a patio ideal for outdoor dining and relaxation. 1 car attached garage is used for storage. Located on a picturesque tree-lined street, this home offers close proximity to parks, the LIRR, and vibrant downtown Garden City. Immaculate and move-in ready, this lovingly updated residence is ready to welcome its next chapter—and its next family.
MLS® Number867709
Laundry Level
Central VacNo
FireplaceNo
Acreage
Exterior
GarageYes
Approx. Age1898
BasementFull
DrivewayAttached
Garage Spaces0
Heat
A/C
Heating Fuel

Extras

Rooms

Change to metres

Bedroom 1:Second FloorNot available
Basement:Lower LevelNot available
Bedroom 2:Second FloorNot available
Dining Room:First FloorNot available
Living Room:First FloorNot available
Bedroom 4:Second FloorNot available
Family Room:First FloorNot available
Bathroom 1:Second FloorNot available
Kitchen:First FloorNot available
Other:First FloorNot available
Bedroom 3:Second FloorNot available
Bathroom 3:Second FloorNot available

Similar Listings

Price History

Jul 21, 2025End Date
$1,300,000Sold Price

Sold

May 28, 2025List Date
$1,299,000List Price
  • Commute

Commute

Starting Address
Destination Address
12 5 Th Pl, Garden City, NY

Curious about your home's value?

Comparable Properties

Explore eXpFind an AgentJoin eXpInvestor RelationsCompany CareersHome Guides
eXp LifeZoocasaSUCCESS®SUCCESS® LendingeXp RevenoseXp CommercialeXp LuxuryAccessibility
Terms and ConditionsPrivacy Rights RequestPrivacy PolicyCookie PolicyBrand GuidelinesHelpSitemap

2219 Rimland Drive, Suite 301, Bellingham, Washington, 98226

1 833-303-0610

[email protected]

eXp REALTY

© 2024 eXp Realty. eXp World Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

DMCA Notice

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply

Fair Housing and Reasonable Accommodations

MLS Compliance Statements

Karen Richards - Designated Managing Broker, Broker Operations - TX

Texas Real Estate Commission information about brokerage services

Texas Real Estate Commission Consumer Protection Notice

eXp Realty® is committed to adhering to the guidelines of The New York State Fair Housing Regulations.The Fair Housing Notice →

*Standardized Operating Procedure for Purchasers of Real Estate Pursuant to Real Property Law 442-H.Learn More →

eXp Realty of California, Inc. | CA DRE# 01878277 | Deborah Penny - Designated Broker

eXp Realty of Southern California, Inc. | CA DRE#01325837 | Jason Crawford – Designated Broker

eXp Realty of Greater Los Angeles, Inc. | CA DRE# 01240990 | Mike Mendibles - Designated Broker

eXp Realty of Northern California, Inc. | CA DRE# 01951343 | Ryan Rosas - Designated Broker

© 2026 eXp Realty. eXp World Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved